| Year | Champion | Runner-up |
| 1934 | Jamaica Red Wings | Sands Point Tigers |
| 1935 | Jamaica Hawks | Bayside-Summit Bears |
| 1936 | tie? | Post-3/30, looking for final game site |
| Stock Exchange Brokers | ||
| Van Cortlandt Broncos | ||
| 1937 | Manhattan Arrows | New York Curb Exchange |
| 1938 | Westchester Rangers | ? |
| 1939 | Jamaica Hawks | |
| 1940 | Sands Point Tigers | Jamaica Hawks |
| 1941 | Exchange Club Brokers | |
| 1942 | Boston Olympic Juniors | Sands Point Tigers |
| 1943 | Brooklyn Arma Torpedoes | Jamaica Hawks |
| 1944 | Sands Point Tigers | Brooklyn Arma Torpedoes |
| 1945 | Jamaica Hawks | Brooklyn Torpedoes |
| 1946 | Brooklyn Torpedos | Manhattan Arrows |
| 1947 | Manhattan Arrows | Jamaica Hawks |
| 1948 | tie | |
| Brooklyn Torpedoes | ||
| Manhattan Arrows | ||
| 1949 | Jamaica Hawks | Manhattan Arrows |
| 1950 | Manhattan Arrows | Sands Point Tigers |
| 1951 | ? | |
| 1952 | Jamaica Hawks | Sands Point Tigers |
•The Lester Patrick Trophy was presented to the winner of the Metropolitan Amateur Hockey League post-season playoffs. A two round championship; first round was a one game playoff, second round sometimes a two game most goals series, other times best of 3. After 1938 it was sometimes just the season pennant itself; post-war a four team round robin series, with a final. It may not have been presented in 1951. The trophy was presented to the league by Lester Patrick, coach of the New York Rangers
•A later trophy called the Lester Patrick Cup was presented to the Western Hockey League champion. The WHL President's Cup was renamed for the 1960-61 season following Lester Patrick's death. A list of winners of the Lester Patrick Cup are as follows:
| 1960-61 | Portland Buckaroos |
| 1961-62 | Edmonton Flyers |
| 1962-63 | San Francisco Seals |
| 1963-64 | San Francisco Seals |
| 1964-65 | Portland Buckaroos |
| 1965-66 | Victoria Maple Leafs |
| 1966-67 | Seattle Totems |
| 1967-68 | Seattle Totems |
| 1968-69 | Vancouver Canucks |
| 1969-70 | Vancouver Canucks |
| 1970-71 | Portland Buckaroos |
| 1971-72 | Denver Spurs |
| 1972-73 | Phoenix Roadrunners |
| 1973-74 | Phoenix Roadrunners |
•See the complete list of W.H.L. Champions from 1944-45 on the Lester Patrick Cup page.
•The Lester Patrick Trophy was presented by the New York Rangers to the N.H.L. to honor Lester Patrick, G.M. and coach of the Rangers for 16 years. It is presented annually since 1966 to individuals for “outstanding service” to American hockey. For a list of winners see this page.
Go to the list of amazing sports lists.
This list compiled and designed by P.S. Luchter.
©All Rights Reserved.
Updated 3/2/2005